Who Founded the Orthodox Church — Which Came First, Catholic or Orthodox — And Which Is Bigger Today?

INTRODUCTION

Learn who founded the Orthodox (Eastern Orthodox) Church, how it developed, when and why it split from Rome, and which of the two (Roman Catholic vs Eastern Orthodox) has more members today. This is a well-sourced blog article with Bible verses, early Church Fathers, historical timeline, comparison tables, and key references for further reading. Vatican News+3Bible Gateway+3newadvent.org+3

---

The Eastern Orthodox Church (often called simply “Orthodoxy”) does not trace its origin to a single human founder; Christians of both East and West believe Jesus Christ founded the Church and sent the apostles to build and lead it. Over centuries that one apostolic Church developed regional centers (Rome, Constantinople, Antioch, Alexandria, Jerusalem), and by 1054 A.D. theological, cultural, and political disputes produced the historic East–West Schism that separated what we now call the Roman Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox communions. Today the Catholic Church is far larger by membership, while the Orthodox churches remain deeply rooted in Eastern Europe, Russia, and parts of the Middle East and Africa. Bible Gateway+2Encyclopedia Britannica+2

---

Who founded the Orthodox Church?

• Founder: Jesus Christ — the Church’s origin is the apostolic community created by Christ, its mission beginning at Pentecost (Acts 2). Bible Gateway

• How Orthodoxy expresses that: Eastern Orthodox teaching and histories trace the Church’s continuous life through the apostolic ministry and succession of bishops from the apostles. The Orthodox Patriarchates expressly state that the Church’s origins lie in Christ and the apostles. goarch.org

Key Bible passages referenced by both traditions: Matthew 16:18 (“…on this rock I will build my church…”) and Acts 2 (Pentecost). Bible Gateway+1

---

Which came first — Roman Catholic or Orthodox?

Short answer: Neither in the sense of “new founding” — both derive from the same original Church established by Christ in the 1st century. The labels “Roman Catholic” and “Eastern Orthodox” describe branches that developed later. The formal, symbolic date for the long-developing separation is 1054 A.D. (the East–West Schism), though the split was the result of centuries of disagreement. Encyclopedia Britannica+1

 

Which has more members today?

Body	Approximate global membership (recent official / scholarly sources)
Roman Catholic Church	~1.3–1.4 billion worldwide (Vatican statistics / Pontifical Yearbook / Annuarium Statisticum Ecclesiae). Vatican News+1
Eastern Orthodox Church (all autocephalous churches combined)	~200–300 million (estimates vary by source; commonly cited range ~220–300M). Wikipedia+1

Bottom line: The Roman Catholic Church is by far the larger single Christian body in global membership; Orthodoxy is the second-largest single communion but significantly smaller than Catholicism in absolute numbers. Vatican News+1

---

Brief historical timeline (visual / ready to paste)

Timeline (key dates)

• c. 30–33 A.D. — Jesus’ ministry, Resurrection, Ascension; Pentecost — birth of the apostolic Church. (Matthew 16:18; Acts 2). Bible Gateway+1

• 1st–4th centuries — Apostles and early bishops establish Christian communities across the Roman Empire; ecumenical councils (Nicaea 325, Constantinople 381) shape core doctrine. Encyclopedia Britannica

• 5th–9th centuries — Doctrinal, liturgical, and political differences grow (language, papal claims, liturgical customs). Encyclopedia Britannica

• 1054 A.D. — Mutual excommunications between Rome and Constantinople mark the Great Schism (East–West Schism). (Symbolic watershed; process began earlier). Encyclopedia Britannica

• Later centuries to present — Separate development of Roman Catholicism (central papal structure) and multiple self-governing Orthodox Churches (autocephalous patriarchates). Modern ecumenical dialogues continue. Encyclopedia Britannica+1

---

Evidence from Scripture and the Early Church:

Biblical basis (often cited):

• Matthew 16:18 — Jesus to Peter: “...on this rock I will build my church...” (used by both sides to argue continuity with apostolic foundation). Bible Gateway

• Acts 2 — Pentecost: apostles filled with the Holy Spirit; missionary expansion begins. Bible Gateway

Early Church Fathers (contemporary witnesses):

• Ignatius of Antioch (early 2nd century): emphasizes bishops and unity (“Wherever the bishop appears, there let the people be…”). This is used by both traditions to show early hierarchical structure. newadvent.org

• Irenaeus of Lyons (late 2nd century): argues for apostolic tradition and succession as the safeguard of true teaching. newadvent.org

• Justin Martyr (mid 2nd century): provides one of the earliest written descriptions of Sunday worship and the Eucharist, showing liturgical continuity. newadvent.org+1

(Primary-source links are listed under “Supporting documents & sources” below.)

---

How did the two traditions diverge?

1. Authority & Papal Primacy: Rome’s claim to universal jurisdiction vs. the East’s view of conciliar collegiality among bishops and patriarchs. Over time this question became central. Encyclopedia Britannica

2. The Filioque Clause: The Western insertion of “and the Son” (Filioque) into the Nicene Creed was a major theological and procedural dispute (East argued it was added without an ecumenical council). Encyclopedia Britannica

3. Language, culture, and politics: Latin West vs. Greek East; changing political realities (fall of Western Empire, rise of Byzantine state) deepened differences. Encyclopedia Britannica

---

Development / evolution of each communion (short)

• Roman Catholic Church: centralized structure under the Bishop of Rome (Pope); global missionary expansion from 15th–20th centuries (colonial era + modern missions) greatly grew Catholic membership worldwide. Vatican documents (Annuarium/Pontifical Yearbook) provide modern statistics and structure. Vatican News+1

• Eastern Orthodox Church: organized as a family of autocephalous (self-governing) churches centered on historic sees (Constantinople, Moscow, Antioch, Alexandria, Jerusalem, etc.). Historically concentrated in Eastern Europe, the Balkans, Russia, the Caucasus, the Middle East; in the modern era some growth and diaspora expansion but far smaller global footprint than Catholicism. goarch.org+1

 

---

Comparison table:

Topic	Roman Catholic Church	Eastern Orthodox Church
Origins	One apostolic Church; developed central papal structure over centuries	Same apostolic origin; developed as several equal patriarchates
Formal split	1054 A.D. (mutual excommunications — historic watershed)	1054 A.D. (same)
Authority	Pope (primacy + universal jurisdiction claimed)	Synodality/collegiality; autocephalous patriarchates
Member count (approx.)	~1.3–1.4 billion (Vatican statistics). Vatican News	~200–300 million (scholarly estimates). Wikipedia+1
Geographic strength	Latin America, large parts of Africa, parts of Asia, Europe, Philippines	Russia, Greece, Balkans, Romania, parts of Middle East & Africa
Liturgy	Latin (historically)/vernacular now; Roman Rite dominant	Byzantine rite and other ancient Eastern rites; highly liturgical, icon-based worship

 

---

Quotations:

From Jesus (Bible): “And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church.” — Matthew 16:18. Bible Gateway

From an early Father (Ignatius of Antioch): “Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.” — Ignatius, Epistle to the Smyrnaeans. newadvent.org

Concise historical note: “The East–West Schism of 1054 was not a single day’s event but the culmination of centuries of differences; 1054 is the symbolic milestone.” — Britannica summary. Encyclopedia Britannica

---

Supporting documents & reliable sources:

(These are the primary references used — they are reputable and readily accessible to readers who want to check primary texts and modern scholarship.)

• Bible (Matthew 16:18; Acts 2) — Bible Gateway (online Bible text). Bible Gateway+1

• Ignatius of Antioch — Epistle to the Smyrnaeans (text & translation) — New Advent / Church Fathers. newadvent.org

• Irenaeus, Against Heresies — New Advent / Church Fathers. newadvent.org

• Justin Martyr, First Apology — primary-source description of 2nd-century worship. newadvent.org

• History of Orthodox Church (official perspective) — Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America (GOARCH) history page. goarch.org

• East–West Schism summary & historical context — Encyclopedia Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica

• Vatican statistics / Annuarium / Pontifical Yearbook 2025 & Annuarium Statisticum Ecclesiae 2023 — Vatican News / Pontifical Yearbook reporting on Catholic membership. Vatican News+1

• Orthodox population & research — Pew Research Center / Orthodox Christianity topic pages (demography & modern trends). Pew Research Center

• Catechism of the Catholic Church (teaching on Church) — Vatican (Catechism online). vatican.va+1

If you want clickable links and a neat “Further reading” section formatted for your blog footer, I can paste full URLs and short annotations for each source.

---

Closing paragraph

Both Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy claim faithful continuity with the Church Christ founded through the apostles. Historically they were one Christian communion for about a thousand years before deep differences produced the East–West Schism. Today the Catholic Church is numerically larger on a global scale, while Orthodoxy preserves ancient eastern liturgical and theological traditions concentrated in particular regions. Whichever side one studies or prefers, the shared early sources — Scripture and the writings of the Church Fathers — remain central to understanding how both traditions view themselves as heirs of the apostolic Church. Bible Gateway+2

 

IF YOU ARE A DEVOTED CATHOLIC AND HAPPY TO DEFEND YOUR CATHOLIC FAITH, YOUR SUPPORT TO CONTINUE OUR MISSION TO DEFEND THE CATHOLIC FAITH, REALLY MATTERS AND WILL ALWAYS BE VALUED AND REMEMBERED!

(Even though this blog comes with Free Domain and Free Hosting plans, there are still costs involve to sustain it, like the reliable internet connection that comes with premium plan, so your support for this endeavor means a lot to me.  Thank you very much.  God Bless).

READ ALSO:

1. The Four Identifying Marks of the True Church Founded by Jesus Christ vs. SDA’s Identifying Marks

2. 🕊️ How to Distinguish Fake Churches from the True Church Established by Jesus Christ

3. The One True Church vs. Thousands of Man-Made Churches: Understanding the Big Difference

4. Are Protestants the True Church Founded by Jesus? Examining the Claims Through Scripture and History