Introduction
In Christian theology one of the key questions is: did the apostles of Jesus Christ believe that He was true God (i.e., fully divine), or was that a later development? In this post we will explore:
-
what the New Testament records about the apostles’ belief regarding Jesus’ divinity;
-
whether any apostle explicitly denied or hesitated in recognising Jesus as God;
-
how early Christian writers (the Apostolic Fathers, Church Fathers) understood Jesus’ divinity;
-
how the doctrine developed historically;
-
what the Catholic Church teaches today (via the Catechism) on this question;
-
and finally draw a conclusion: was there any apostle who did not believe that Jesus is true God?
1. What the New Testament shows about the apostles and Jesus’ divinity
Let’s begin with primary biblical evidence (since the apostles lived and acted in that era).
Key texts:
-
John the Apostle’s Gospel: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.” (John 1:1) This clearly affirms the Word (Logos) was divine. Catholic Answers+3Life, Hope & Truth+3The Daily Declaration+3
-
Likewise, John 1:14: “And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us.” This applies the Logos to the human Jesus.
-
In the Synoptic Gospels, Peter’s confession: “… ‘You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.’” (Matthew 16:16) — Peter acknowledges Jesus as Messiah and Son of God. 21stcr.org+2Christianity Stack Exchange+2
-
Other NT passages: e.g., Hebrews 1:8 (quoting God to the Son: “Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever”).
-
Passages emphasising creation by Christ (Colossians 1:15-16; John 1:3) which support divinity.
Key observation:
There is strong scriptural basis that at least some apostles (or apostolic authors) believed Jesus was divine. For example John (the author) clearly affirms “the Word was God” and became flesh.
But: Is there any explicit apostle who did not believe Jesus was true God?
No text in the New Testament clearly records an apostle publicly saying “Jesus is not God” or denying His divinity. Some analyses suggest that earlier Christian belief may have had a variety of Christologies (see adoptionism, “low Christology”) but that does not prove an apostle denied Christ’s divinity. For example, scholars such as Bart D. Ehrman suggest earliest Christians may have viewed Jesus as exalted rather than inherently divine. Christianity Stack Exchange+3The Bart Ehrman Blog+3We Dare To Say+3
Thus: from the New Testament record we cannot identify an apostle who unequivocally denied that Jesus is God.
2. The Apostolic Fathers and early Christian testimony
After the apostles, the generation of early Christian leaders known as the Apostolic Fathers (roughly late 1st – early 2nd century) provide further evidence of the belief in Christ’s divinity.
Key witnesses and quotes
-
Ignatius of Antioch (c. 50-117 AD) wrote: “for our God, Jesus Christ” (in his letter to the Ephesians). Stand to Reason+1
-
Polycarp of Smyrna (c. 69-155) was described as a disciple of the Apostle John; his letter says: “to all who will yet believe in our Lord and God Jesus Christ and in his Father...” Stand to Reason+1
-
Many scholars note the generation of Apostolic Fathers “unanimously affirmed that Jesus is the one true God.” carm.org+1
Significance
This shows that very early (immediately post-apostolic) Christian leaders believed and taught that Jesus is divine — so the belief goes back to the first or second generation of Christians.
Caveat on “unanimous” and development
While these early Christian writers certainly affirm Christ’s divinity, the doctrine of the Trinity (the terminology “homoousios”, etc.) was still being worked out in the 2nd and 3rd centuries. One writer notes: “traditional Trinitarian doctrine is seen in bits throughout the Apostolic Fathers … not as elaborated and carefully articulated as the Nicene-era would be, but the broad understanding is definitely there.” Tis Mercy All
Thus the belief in Christ’s divinity was present early, though the language and systematic theology matured over time.
3. Development / Evolution of the Doctrine
Here we trace how the belief matured over time, from apostolic era to formalized doctrine.
Timeline overview
Key debates and alternative views
-
Some early Christians held “adoptionist” or “exaltationist” Christologies: Jesus a man who was exalted to divine status by God after resurrection. The Bart Ehrman Blog+1
-
The Arian controversy: Arius (c. 250-336) argued the Son was a created being, not co-eternal with the Father. The Nicene Creed rejected this. Wikipedia+1
-
While the doctrine of the Trinity and the full phraseology of “fully God and fully man” came later, the seeds of the belief in Christ’s divinity are found in the earliest Christianity.
4. The Catholic Church’s Teaching
The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) expresses the Church’s teaching on Christ’s divinity and the apostolic faith. Some key points:
-
The Church teaches that Jesus Christ is “true God and true man.”
-
This belief is handed down from the apostles (Apostolic Succession) and affirmed by the early Church.
-
The Church rejects any view that Jesus is a mere creature or that His divinity is a later invention.
(If you like, I can pull specific CCC paragraph numbers.)
5. Conclusion – Did any Apostle fail to believe Jesus is true God?
Putting together the evidence:
-
There is no credible record in the New Testament of any of the apostles publicly denying or refusing to affirm that Jesus is God.
-
Apostolic-era Christian writings (Apostolic Fathers) affirm Christ’s divinity.
-
The doctrinal development shows belief in Christ’s deity from the earliest times, even if the technical phrasing matured later.
-
The Catholic Church’s teaching is that the apostles handed on the faith that Jesus is fully God and fully man.
So, in answer to your question: as far as the historical and doctrinal evidence shows, no apostle is recorded as not believing that Jesus Christ is true God.
READ ALSO:
“I Am the Alpha and the Omega”: Refuting the INC Claim that Christ Is Not God
✝️ Who Were the Apostles and Early Christians Who Proclaimed Jesus Christ as God? — Scriptural, Historical, and Doctrinal Proofs Against Arianism and INC
No comments:
Post a Comment